Monday, October 26, 2026

Fixed Form, Live Attention: Learning in the AI Era

Are my cognitive skills going down because I use AI too much? This question has been doing the rounds in my peer circles for some time now… and it usually leads to a bigger one. If AI can answer most (if not all) of our questions, do we still need formal classes? Isn't AI a better disseminator of knowledge than most lecturers?

It is a fair question. In many colleges, the lecturer still walks in with notes and reads them out while students furiously copy them down. Book sales, I am told, have dropped sharply because information is available aplenty. Content now comes in every form, and moves easily from one form to another. Upload a PDF on any topic to an AI notebook tool such as NotebookLM, and within minutes you can draw out summaries, flashcards for an exam, multiple-choice questions or a mind map. And when you tire of these, you can turn the same material into an audio podcast, a debate, a presentation, or even a video… The list is endless.

So, what is the role of the educator? And, more importantly, are rote learning and knowing the fundamentals still relevant?

This is where I think we can take a leaf out of Kalaripayattu.

A tradition carried by the voice

Kalaripayattu, one of the oldest martial art forms, was once a serious method of warfare and of settling duels, especially among the chieftains who ruled the region we now know as Kerala. Under British rule, the practice was suppressed in the early nineteenth century  and it went underground, to resurface almost hundred and forty years later. Practitioners credit the vaithari (the spoken commands, called out by the master, that set the order and pace of each routine) with carrying the sequences through that dark period.

The art was, and still is, taught in four stages:

  1. Meythari: body exercises that build flexibility, balance and agility
  2. Kolthari: training with wooden weapons
  3. Ankathari: training with metal weapons
  4. Verumkai: bare-handed combat

The order matters. The student first becomes conscious of their own body. Weapon training then teaches them to focus, to be present in the present. And finally, the weapon becomes an extension of the body itself. Phillip Zarrilli, who studied and taught Kalaripayattu for decades, takes the title of his book from this ideal: the state in which the body "becomes all eyes" (Zarrilli 1998).

What the theater saw

Eugenio Barba, founder of Odin Teatret, describes the same phenomenon from the stage. In A Dictionary of Theatre Anthropology (Barba and Savarese 2006), he separates the techniques we use in daily life from the "extra-daily" techniques a performer trains, which put the body in form before it expresses anything at all. In his own company, actors improvise, then fix the improvisation and repeat it until every detail is absorbed. At first, the actor feels stiff and mechanical. Once the actions are fully absorbed, though, the performance becomes spontaneous again (Barba 1986). The actor, therefore, is now ready to improvise.

Choreographed, but never mechanical

It is exactly this kind of preparation, I believe, that sharpens cognitive skill.

Most of the movement in Kalaripayattu is choreographed. There is a vaithari for every practice session, even for the urumi (the flexible sword). Unlike karate, there is no free sparring. In my view, the reason is the risk: the training aims at the vital spots, so even an accidental blow can do serious harm.

And yet, it is not mechanical. Two sparring partners have to be totally aligned and aware of each other's movements. When the stick does not come up in time to block a strike to the head, the striking partner has to sense it and stop the stick mid-way. With metal weapons, this becomes even more pronounced. The sequence is fixed; the attention is live. Movement scientists have a lovely phrase for this, which goes back to the Russian physiologist Nikolai Bernstein: "repetition without repetition" (Bernstein 1967).

From tacit to explicit, and back again

In Knowledge Management, we see the same journey in how knowledge moves from tacit to explicit, and then back to tacit again: the cycle that Nonaka and Takeuchi described in The Knowledge-Creating Company (1995). The master's skill is tacit. The vaithari and the sequences make it explicit. Through years of practice, the student absorbs it until it becomes tacit once more, this time as his own, ready to be reshaped into his own version.

An old Zen saying, attributed to the Chan master Qingyuan Weixin, puts this beautifully. Before study, mountains are mountains and rivers are rivers. With some learning, they cease to be. And with true understanding, mountains are mountains again, and rivers are rivers again.

There is a catch, of course. This only works if the student knows what is happening: he has to internalize the explicit knowledge and make it his own. That part cannot be outsourced.

So, where does AI fit in?

The early research gives me some pause, though it is too soon to call it settled. A study of 666 people in Switzerland found that heavy use of AI tools went hand in hand with lower critical-thinking scores, especially among younger users (Gerlich 2025). A survey of knowledge workers by Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon found that the more people trusted the AI, the less critical thinking they reported doing (Lee et al. 2025). Neither study proves that AI causes the decline. They do show a pattern worth watching.

The most telling result, for me, came from a small study at the MIT Media Lab (Kosmyna et al. 2025). Students who wrote essays with ChatGPT showed the lowest brain engagement, and struggled to recall what they had just written. But those who first wrote on their own, and only then turned to the AI, did well. Body first, weapon later. Meythari before kolthari!

The role of the educator, then, is less that of a reader of notes and more that of the gurukkal (the Kalari master): designing the sequence, calling out the vaithari, and watching closely for the moment a student is not ready.

That, in essence, is my answer. I do believe AI has a real role to play in education, going forward. But students still need to hone their own cognitive skills. Remembering and understanding, the lower rungs of Bloom's taxonomy, are now what AI does best. Examinations, and a student's preparedness, will increasingly be judged by the ability to analyze, evaluate and create. More importantly, even when using AI, students need to know when and why a decision was taken, and when it must be handed back to a human.

Like the sparring partner who stops the stick mid-air, the real skill lies in sensing when not to follow through.

Thursday, October 08, 2026

Carrying a Load of Wood - From PISA Scores to the Modern Gurukulam

 

sthāṇurayaṃ bhārahāraḥ kilābhūd adhītya vedaṃ na vijānāti yo’rtham |

He who studies the Veda but does not understand its meaning is like a post – a mere bearer of a burden.

– Yāska, Nirukta 1.18

A few days ago, I came across a thought-provoking post on LinkedIn by my BITS classmate, Manas Chakrabarti. Writing about the OECD’s Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA, as it is popularly known), Manas wondered why countries like Finland and Iceland have seen unexpected declines in their scores, while others continue to do well.

His post stayed with me. It touched a raw nerve in how we, in India, think about learning.

What does PISA actually test?

PISA is not a board examination. It does not ask a 15-year-old to reproduce a memorized formula or write out a textbook chapter. Instead, it tests what one might call application literacy: can the student read an unfamiliar data table, weigh two competing arguments in an ambiguous passage, or use a basic scientific principle to solve a real-world problem?

In other words, it tests the upper floors of Bloom’s taxonomy – analysis, evaluation, and synthesis – rather than the ground floor of recall.

India’s brief brush with PISA in 2009 (two states, Tamil Nadu and Himachal Pradesh, took part) was, therefore, an uncomfortable mirror. Even our better students struggled once the questions were stripped of the familiar textbook templates. We had built an extraordinary capacity for retention; what we had not built was the habit of reasoning from first principles.

The misunderstood Gurukulam

When we look back at India’s classical tradition of education, it is easy to assume it was simply a culture of oral memorization. Memorization (kaṇṭhastha, learning “by throat”) certainly existed. In an age without printing presses, it was the library and the index rolled into one. It was, however, never the destination.

The tradition itself cautions against learning by heart without understanding. Yāska’s line at the top of this piece says it bluntly: the one who recites without grasping the meaning is a post carrying a load of wood.

Real scholarship was dialectical. Students were trained in Tarka-śāstra (the science of reasoning) and Vāda (formal, good-faith debate, as set out in the Nyāya Sūtra). The method was demanding:

It is this discipline of steel-manning the other side before answering it that makes the classical method so modern. In fact, it maps remarkably well onto the very competencies PISA sets out to measure. That this was the norm at centers of learning like Nalanda and Takshashila is often said; that it was the norm in the śāstric tradition is beyond doubt.

Can the NEP bridge the gap?

The National Education Policy 2020 diagnosed the rote-learning problem with remarkable clarity. Its prescription – Competency-Based Education (CBE), and board examinations that include case-based and analytical questions – is a long-overdue roadmap.

Changing an entrenched classroom culture, however, is a different matter. As long as entrance examinations such as the JEE and NEET remain hyper-competitive elimination sieves, the classroom will, therefore, keep defaulting to pattern-matching and speed drills. Teachers teach to the test because parents and students demand it. The policy intent is sound; the journey from rote execution to genuine inquiry has only begun.

A bold experiment: Ayurveda after Class 10

Against this backdrop, an interesting experiment is taking shape. The Central Sanskrit University (CSU), working within the framework of the National Commission for Indian System of Medicine (NCISM), has opened a residential, Gurukulam-style pathway to the BAMS degree for students who have just finished Class 10.

The idea is to step outside the lecture hall. Instead of learning Ayurveda only through translated textbooks and borrowed pharmacology templates, students begin with a Pre-Ayurveda foundation: the Darśanas (the philosophical systems, including the logic and natural philosophy on which Ayurveda rests), the classical texts read in Sanskrit, and clinical observation alongside a teacher.

The promise

If it is done with rigor, this model could bring back the observational acumen that this kind of medicine demands. Diagnosis in Ayurveda is not a checklist. Whether it is reading the pulse (Nāḍī Parīkṣāor reading a patient’s daily routine, it calls for years at the bedside, a mentor at one’s elbow, and the ability to reason in context.

The pitfalls

Any such venture also carries real risks:

a)        The first danger is swapping one kind of rote learning for another: graduates who can recite verses in perfect meter, but who falter when an actual patient walks in. That would be Yāska’s post all over again, merely carrying a heavier load.

b)       The second is drift. The study of logic and natural philosophy needs clear boundaries, so that it sharpens clinical reasoning instead of turning into a broad, unfocused course in culture.

c)        The third is isolation. A Vaidya who cannot read a lab report, or work alongside a modern hospital, risks practicing in an intellectual silo. The patient, after all, does not care which system the insight came from.

Looking back to look forward

Does this mean we must return to the forest schools of antiquity? Nostalgia is no substitute for an education strategy.

The real opportunity lies in combining the best of both. Digital simulations, data analytics, and interactive tools can do the heavy lifting of carrying information to students. That frees the teacher to do what the Gurukulam did best: long mentorship, honest debate, and the patient application of first principles.

Reform, thus, does not ask us to choose between tradition and technology. It asks us to stop producing cooks who are lost without a recipe – and to start producing students who can think, question, and, yes, heal.

What do you think? Have you seen a classroom, ancient or modern, that genuinely teaches students to argue the other side first? I look forward to your comments.